
August 30, 2013. 91-minute dharma talk given by Thich Nhat Hanh from Blue Cliff Monastery in Pine Bush, New York during the 2013 Nourishing Great Togetherness teaching tour. This is the final dharma talk for the 6-day retreat with the theme Transformation and Healing – The Art of Suffering .
Summary
This talk presents a detailed teaching on the Buddhist understanding of true love, suffering, and liberation, delivered on the final day of a retreat on the art of suffering. The speaker explains that the Buddha teaches not only how to suffer, but also how to transform suffering into joy, happiness, and love. The central theme is that love is not consumption but offering: offering joy, well-being, and relief from suffering. True love is described through the four Brahma-viharas: maitri, karuna, mudita, and upeksha. The first element, maitri, is defined as loving-kindness or true friendship. It means the capacity to offer happiness to oneself and to another person. The speaker emphasizes that one must first learn to generate happiness within oneself before being able to offer it to others. This is connected to the practice of mindful breathing, especially exercises that bring the mind home to the body and help one recognize the conditions of happiness already present. The second element, karuna, is compassion, understood not merely as suffering with another person, but as the capacity to help transform suffering and remove pain. The speaker insists that one must understand one’s own suffering before being able to help another person suffer less. The third element, mudita, is joy. A relationship without joy is not true love. True love should create joy for both people, and joy is presented as a sign that love is alive. The fourth element, upeksha, is equanimity or, in the Plum Village interpretation, non-discrimination and inclusiveness. In true love, there is no separation between lover and beloved; one person’s suffering becomes the other’s suffering, and one person’s happiness becomes the other’s happiness. The speaker uses the image of two hands helping each other to illustrate non-discrimination, harmony, and the absence of superiority or inferiority complexes. True love, he says, grows without boundaries and should eventually include all beings without discrimination based on race, nationality, religion, or skin color. A major section of the talk connects true love with the practice of mindful breathing and the ten exercises of breathing. The speaker explains how the first exercises cultivate awareness of the body, feelings, and mental formations, while later exercises help generate joy, happiness, and the ability to handle pain. He then introduces the practice of “selective watering,” a key Plum Village method associated with true diligence. This means not watering negative seeds such as anger, fear, jealousy, violence, or despair, and instead watering positive seeds such as compassion, understanding, and joy. He describes this as a practical method for both individuals and couples, even suggesting that partners can make a “peace treaty” or “happiness treaty” to agree not to trigger each other’s negative seeds. The talk also emphasizes loving speech and deep listening as essential practices for reconciliation. The speaker describes retreats in which people, after calming themselves and recognizing their own suffering, become able to listen deeply to the suffering of others. He gives examples of couples, families, and even Israelis and Palestinians who have used these practices to restore communication and heal relationships. The key to deep listening is to listen with the intention of helping the other person suffer less, without interrupting or reacting defensively. Loving speech and compassionate listening are presented as a bodhisattva practice associated with Avalokita or Quan Yin. The latter part of the talk focuses on concentration and liberation through the three doors of liberation: emptiness, signlessness, and aimlessness. Emptiness is explained not as nothingness, but as the absence of separate self-existence. A flower, a person, a son, or a daughter exists only through interbeing with the whole cosmos. Signlessness means not being trapped by appearances or fixed images, especially in the face of death or loss. Aimlessness means not running after objects of craving, fame, or even enlightenment itself, because the deepest reality is already present in the here and now. These teachings are linked to the insight of no birth and no death, and to the freedom that comes from letting go of notions such as being and non-being. The talk concludes with a moving story about Anathapindika, a lay disciple of the Buddha, who was guided by Sariputra and Ananda as he was dying. Through recollection of the Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha, and through contemplation of emptiness and no birth/no death, he found peace and died with a smile. The speaker uses this story to encourage listeners to build and sustain a sangha, continue walking meditation in daily life, and keep watering the good seeds in themselves and their loved ones. The overall message is that true love, mindfulness, compassion, and insight into interbeing are practical paths to healing suffering and living freely in the present moment.
Search every word, jump to any moment, and follow along with the audio.



